How far in advance do I need to place a custom cake order?

We ask for at least 48 hours of lead time on all custom cake orders. This window is tied directly to our bakery partners' bake schedules and our internal ordering process. Placing your order early gives our partners the time they need to bake, finish, and prepare your cake properly. For larger or more detailed celebration cakes, reaching out even earlier is a good idea to make sure everything comes together the way you want it.

Do you offer gluten-free cake options?

Yes, gluten-free custom cakes are available. When you place your order, simply let us know about any dietary requirements and we will connect you with the right bakery partner who can accommodate your needs. We want every guest at your table to be able to enjoy the celebration, so we do our best to make sure dietary preferences are taken into account from the start of the ordering process.

What specialty cake flavors can I choose from?

We work with a curated network of Arizona artisan bakers, so flavor options can vary depending on the partner fulfilling your order. When you reach out, share your preferences and any specific flavor ideas you have in mind. Our team will do their best to match you with a baker whose specialty cake flavors align with what you are looking for. We encourage you to be as specific as possible so we can set accurate expectations before confirming your order.

How do I place a custom cake order?

Custom cake orders are placed through the Simply Bread app, which is our preferred ordering platform. The app also sends automated SMS reminders so you stay informed about your order status. When submitting your order, include details like the occasion, desired serving size, flavor preferences, and any dietary needs. If you have questions before ordering, you are welcome to visit us in store in Sierra Vista and we are happy to walk you through the process in person.

Are the cakes baked on-site at The Neighborhood Table SV?

Our cakes are not baked on-site. The Neighborhood Table SV operates as a curated bakery retail hub, meaning we partner with trusted Arizona artisan bakeries to fulfill orders. This model allows us to offer a wider range of high-quality, made-to-order products than a single on-site kitchen could produce. Every partner is selected for their craft and commitment to quality, so you can feel confident about what you are receiving.

Custom Cakes in Sierra Vista | The Neighborhood Table SV

Not every celebration looks the same, and your cake should not either. Our custom cake orders are fulfilled through a curated network of skilled Arizona bakery partners who bring artisan cake design to life for our Sierra Vista community. From layered celebration cakes with specialty flavors to simple, beautifully finished creations, each order is handled with the same attention to quality that defines everything at The Neighborhood Table SV. We source from makers who take their craft seriously, so you can feel confident about what ends up on your table.

Custom cake orders require a 48-hour lead time so our bakery partners have the time they need to bake and finish your order properly. We ask that you reach out with as much detail as possible: the occasion, any flavor preferences, serving size, and any dietary requirements. Orders are placed through the Simply Bread app, which also sends you automated reminders so nothing slips through the cracks. We are a family-run shop, and we take the time to make sure your order is handled personally from start to finish.

At The Neighborhood Table SV, every product has a purpose and a person behind it. Our custom cakes are not produced in a factory or shipped from a warehouse. They come from real Arizona bakers who care about their work, curated by Solomon and Alicia Buckhanan with the Sierra Vista community in mind. We serve families, professionals, and organizations across Sierra Vista, Huachuca City, Bisbee, Tombstone, and beyond. When you order a custom cake through us, you are supporting local makers and getting something genuinely made for your table.

Every custom cake starts with the details. Download our order form, fill in what you have in mind, and bring it in or send it over with your preorder so we can match it with the right baking partner.

Size & cake type

9" round, quarter / half / full sheet — white, chocolate, marble or carrot.

Icing & filling

Buttercream, cream cheese, ganache, fudge and more, with fillings from lemon and raspberry to tiramisu and tres leches.

Wording on the cake

Exactly as you want it piped, so nothing is lost in translation.

Decorating theme

Spring flowers, balloons, confetti, sports, graduation, baby shower, southwestern and others.

Colors

Flower, lettering and border colors, plus a full decoration colour chart.

Custom Cake Pricing

See our full pricing list HERE.

How far in advance do I need to place a custom cake order?
We ask for at least 48 hours of lead time on all custom cake orders. This window is tied directly to our bakery partners' bake schedules and our internal ordering process. Placing your order early gives our partners the time they need to bake, finish, and prepare your cake properly. For larger or more detailed celebration cakes, reaching out even earlier is a good idea to make sure everything comes together the way you want it.
Do you offer gluten-free cake options?
Yes, gluten-free custom cakes are available. When you place your order, simply let us know about any dietary requirements and we will connect you with the right bakery partner who can accommodate your needs. We want every guest at your table to be able to enjoy the celebration, so we do our best to make sure dietary preferences are taken into account from the start of the ordering process.
What specialty cake flavors can I choose from?
We work with a curated network of Arizona artisan bakers, so flavor options can vary depending on the partner fulfilling your order. When you reach out, share your preferences and any specific flavor ideas you have in mind. Our team will do their best to match you with a baker whose specialty cake flavors align with what you are looking for. We encourage you to be as specific as possible so we can set accurate expectations before confirming your order.
How do I place a custom cake order?
Custom cake orders are placed through the Simply Bread app, which is our preferred ordering platform. The app also sends automated SMS reminders so you stay informed about your order status. When submitting your order, include details like the occasion, desired serving size, flavor preferences, and any dietary needs. If you have questions before ordering, you are welcome to visit us in store in Sierra Vista and we are happy to walk you through the process in person.
Are the cakes baked on-site at The Neighborhood Table SV?
Our cakes are not baked on-site. The Neighborhood Table SV operates as a curated bakery retail hub, meaning we partner with trusted Arizona artisan bakeries to fulfill orders. This model allows us to offer a wider range of high-quality, made-to-order products than a single on-site kitchen could produce. Every partner is selected for their craft and commitment to quality, so you can feel confident about what you are receiving.